Few stats about Immigrants

I came across few comments on various blogs, about how Indians are taking away jobs, working for penuts and if they are send back would fix all the issue.

As I have mentioned in earlier posts, everyone is entitled to their views but hatred comments just by believes without any factual data is not healthy for any discussion or society.

I have pull together some data, which may be helpful to everyone. Also by providing such data by NO means is winning drumroll that proves Indians(Asians) are any superior but it just explains, how few motivated people, who have decided to join the american dream ( http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Dream ) are working hard to their way up.

How Indian are doing in US?
According to recent census report , there were as many as 2,843,391 persons of Indian origin living in the United states, constituting 0.9% of the total U.S. population. The median household income for US residents born in India is $91,195 against a $50,740 average for the total population, a recent US survey has revealed. According to the same report, the overall median household income for foreign- born and native US residents is $46,881 and $51,249 respectively. (Reference: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indian_American)

According to the 2000 census, about 64% of Indian Americans have attained a Bachelor’s degree or more.(compared to 28% nationally, and 44% average for all Asian American groups). Almost 40% of all Indians have a master’s, doctorate or other professional degree, which is five times the national average. (Source: The Indian American Centre for Political Awareness.)

Indian Americans own 50% of all economy lodges and 35% of all hotels in the United States, which have a combined marke t value of almost $40 billion. (Source: Little India Magazine). In 2002, there were over 223,000 Asian Indian-owned firms in the U.S., employing more than 610,000 workers, and generating more than $88 billion in revenue. (Reference: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indian_American)

How h-1b are doing?

Please read full report at link below,
Reference:  National Foundation for American Policy Publication: H1B visa by numbers 2010 and Beyond (http://www.nfap.com/pdf/1003h1b.pdf) 

There are about 1 million people employed with h-1b visa,  (Reference: http://h1b-visa-data.com/states.html )

In 2009, H1B holders constituted only 0.06% of the total American civilian labor force. It is a myth that H1B holders are completely taking over Americans’ jobs.

“New H-1B visa holders in the United States accounted for 0.06 percent of the U.S. labor force in 2009. Including those petitions exempt from counting against the H-1B quota, a total of 85,133 new H-1B petitions were approved by USCIS in FY 2009. That compares to the U.S. civilian labor force of approximately 154 million in 2009.”

“A key premise of critics remains that companies hire H-1B professionals to the exclusion of Americans. If one looks at the numbers this assertion makes little sense. Almost all companies that employ H-1B visa holders have a workforce with U.S. workers accounting for 85 percent to 99 percent. The relatively few businesses with more than 15 percent of workers on H-1B visas are “H-1B dependent” and must adhere to a stricter set of labor rules.”

H-1BS AND EDUCATION LEVELS

Contrary to assertions that H-1B visa holders are not highly skilled, official data for FY 2008 show 57 percent of recent H-1B professionals earned a master’s degree or higher, according to the Department of Homeland Security. Forty-one percent earned a master’s degree, 11 percent earned a Ph.D. and 5 percent a professional degree.27 In 2007, U.S. universities awarded about half of master’s degrees and 73 percent of Ph.D.s in electrical engineering to foreign nationals, according to the National Science Foundation.

IMMIGRANT ENTREPRENEURS

A study by Stuart Anderson and Michaela Platzer conducted for the National Venture Capital Association found “Over the past 15 years, immigrants have started 25 percent of U.S. public companies that were venture-backed, a high percentage of the most innovative companies in America . . . The largest U.S. venture-backed public companies started by immigrants include Intel, Solectron, Sanmina-SCI, Sun Microsystems, eBay, Yahoo!, and Google.”

Duke University research that involved interviews with executives at U.S. technology and engineering companies found essentially the same results as the National Venture Capital Association study. “Of the 2054 companies we interviewed, 25.3 percent reported that at least one of their key founders was an immigrant. Extrapolating from this sample, we estimate that all companies founded by immigrants from 1995 to 2005 produced $52 billion in sales and employed 450,000 workers in 2005,” according to Vivek Wadhwa, AnnaLee Saxenian, Ben Rissing and Gary Gereffi.

There are numerous studies been performed on how America can get more competitive by skilled labor,

High-Tech Immigrant Entrepreneurship in the United States
http://archive.sba.gov/advo/research/rs349tot.pdf

Education, Entrepreneurship and Immigration
http://sites.kauffman.org/pdf/entrep_immigrants_2_61207.pdf 

“On average, 31 percent of the engineering and technology companies founded from 1995 to 2005 in the eleven technology centers that we surveyed had an immigrant as a key founder. This contrasts with the national average of 25.4 percent. Tech centers with a disproportionate percentage of immigrant startups relative to their state averages include Silicon Valley, with 52.4 percent (compared with a state average of 38.8 percent); New York City with 43.8 percent (vs. 26 percent); Seattle with 23.4 percent (vs. 11.3 percent); and Research Triangle Park with 18.7 percent (vs. 13.9 percent.)”

SKILLED FOREIGN NATIONALS AND TAXES

A March 2009 study by Arlene Holen for the Technology Policy Institute found “highly skilled immigrants pay substantially more in taxes than they receive in federal benefits.” According to the research, “The relaxation of green card constraints proposed in the Comprehensive Immigration Reform Act of 2006 could have increased labor earnings and GDP by approximately $34 billion in the tenth year following enactment and had a net positive effect on the budget of $34 to $47 billion over ten years. . . . Relaxation of H-1B caps under the Comprehensive Immigration Reform Act of 2007 could have increased labor earnings and GDP by $60 billion in the tenth year following enactment and improved the federal budget’s bottom line by $64 to $86 billion over ten years.”

FOREIGN NATIONALS LEAVING U.S., VISA POLICY A FACTOR

A survey of more than 1,000 Indian and Chinese professionals who left the United States and returned to their native countries found many individuals perceive greater opportunities in their countries of birth than ever before. The March 2009 findings from Duke University and University of California, Berkeley researchers send a signal that America cannot take it for granted that outstanding international students, researchers and professionals from around the world will always want to stay and work in the United States. “The responses to our survey seemed to indicate that returnees’ departures were not related solely to preferences for starting a business in their home countries or to perceptions of possibilities of further professional advancement in their home countries,” concluded co-authors Vivek Wadhwa (Duke University), AnnaLee Saxenian (University of California, Berkeley), Richard Freeman (Harvard University), Gary Gereffi (Duke University) and Alex Salkever (Duke University). “Returnees showed a strong preference for their home country because of family and personal considerations.” 9

“A majority of respondents indicated that they would at least consider returning to the U.S. if they could get a visa and a good job. Most likely the good job is the key here, as visa considerations did not weigh heavily in their decision to leave. Fewer than one-third of respondents had permanent-residency status, however, and it is possible that, though visa issues may not be perceived as a major reason to leave, job difficulties resulting from restrictive visa policies could be playing a major role in spurring the exodus,” the authors found.10

In fact, the survey found that only 34 percent of Indians without a green card said “No,” they would not return to the United States “if offered a permanent resident visa (green card) and a suitable job opportunity.” The remaining 64 percent said yes or maybe they would return (26 percent said yes, 40 percent said maybe). The results were similar for Chinese professionals without a green card who had returned to China, with 27 percent saying they

would not return to America if offered permanent residence and a suitable job opportunity, with the remaining 73 percent saying yes or maybe they would come back to America (17.5 percent yes, 55 percent maybe).

Approximately one-third of Indian temporary visa holders (32.6 percent) said U.S. visas/permits contributed to their decision to return home to India. Twenty-two percent of Chinese said visa issues contributed to their decision to leave America and return to China.

or may be all this stats are just sham or may be the next Steve Jobs is foreign born, U.S. educated and likely on a plane home. Read more: http://www.businessinsider.com/the-next-steve-jobs-is-foreign-born-american-educated-and-on-a-plane-home-2011-12#ixzz1fiQOCA4T

Where Will Happiness Strike Next

Immigrants taking away jobs?

I recently came across article on Forbes, “America’s Pastime Should Be Baseball, Not Complaints about Immigrants“.

Many fans and commentators marveled at the way Dominican-born outfielder Nelson Cruz propelled the Texas Rangers into the World Series by hitting a record 6 home runs in 6 games during the American League Championship Series. Some people argued the Tigers pitchers should not have thrown Cruz so many fastballs. Others said they never saw such a display of power. But here’s one thing nobody said: “Nelson Cruz took a job away from an American outfielder.”
…
more

If you have not read it yet, Its something to read and think about.

More in Support of H.R. 3012

Posting following on behalf of  USGC5,

7% is an arbitrary number and people from I/C are getting victimized because of that “arbitrary, ill-thought, out-dated 7%” figure. Spillover tried to distribute the unused visas to help the victims and in that process it might have added up to 21%. Any percentage will not undo the fact that existing preferential treatment is “Unfair and Discriminatory”!

Having said that, I wish to pose a couple of questions for the people who do not support HR 3012.

1) Given the same abilities/qualifications, you have a ROW person coming late in the game and getting GC right away just because he is born from a less-subscribed country, ignoring the talented people already waiting for GC. How is it reasonable to justify that the newbie from ROW is more talented & worthy, than an I/C who is gaining relevant experience and still waiting!

2) GC is for a future employment and when one has to wait >10 years (with no clear end of wait in sight) to get a GC based on that position (assuming it would be still available after 10 years). Don’t you see the obvious disconnect here? Isn’t there something fundamentally wrong here?

3) For EB based GC, diversity is superfluous and a hollow claim! EB category is for business’s to find and fill the talent from where-ever it exists; any government will like to see the business’s thriving and not be “hostage” to the country-cap!

4) If the country-cap is going to retrogress the I/C people so severely, it not unrealistic to foresee a situation in which the potential employers will shun I/C people due the uncertainty in the GC process. Though they will not advertise this policy openly, it is quite possible that they will screen resumes taking that into account (it will be quite evident from resume and be able to judge where one would hail from and so, it is not necessary to ask this question in interviews), which is nothing but “Discrimination”!

What is the guarantee that such a discrimination is not possible? If everyone is on the same ladder, such a country-based discrimination is not possible, right?

Why do I support H.R. 3012?

There are lot of myths, misconception and rhetoric about H.R. 3012. Everyone is entitled to their views and free in supporting something or not but people often don’t  understand the problem in entirety and comment by their believes and not by facts.

Current problem,

– When students come to US for higher education, they are not limited by their country.
– When they get a Master’s or PHD degree, they are not limited by their country.
– When they get a job in Apple, Google or Facebook, they are not limited by their country.
– When a company applies for their H-1b or labor certificate, they are not limited by their country.
– When their labor certificate gets approved (which has some rigorous check by USCIS and department of labor) and apply for their I-140, they are not limited by their country.
– Now, why do you to need to know the applicant’s country at the final stage of Green-Card?

If there is a good answer to the questions above then bill is debatable to the point, why the employment based immigration should not be first-come and first-serve?

Does H.R. 3012 increase number of visas?

HR 3012 *****DOES NOT***** increase any numeric limit… It’s an effort to fix broken Employment based Immigration system and makes it first-come first-serve basis. Keep in mind that the people benefiting from it are already in US and employed by US companies LEGALLY.

H.R. 3012 will flood low skilled immigrants to US and hurt diversity.

The bill is not the answer to immigration at large and their impact on US employment or society, that should be discussed separately. Nor it is the answers to the rhetoric about, how this would hurt the diversity. (there are other classes of visa that accepts applicants based on Diversity, Refugees, Asylees that India and China are not qualified for already.) The bill is a fix to one and only one thing, that is making the process fairer by first-come, first-served basis — with no country-based limits.


Other observation and questions

As moderator of  http://skilledimmigrant.blogspot.com/  would not accept my answers, I will be posting them here,

Question:
In 2010 49,087 of visas of the 148,343 immigrant visas granted in the employment based categories were awarded to applicants born in either India or China. This accounts for ~33% of the total EB visas granted. Applicants from India alone were granted ~20% of the visas and not the 7% as stated (http://www.dhs.gov/xlibrary/assets/statistics/yearbook/2010/ois_yb_2010.pdf)

Answer:
From the data-set provided in the link, of 1,042,625 total Green Card issued for 2010, 49,087 ( ~4%) allocated to people (India or China) who are already working in US legally, most likely after their Master’s or PHD. Why a hue and cry about 4% workers, who are here Legally and Skilled in STEM (with most holding Mater’s or PHD). These people currently have to wait for their GC from 5-10 years because they are from India or China. How is that fair?

Question:
An argument in favor of this bill is that this bill helps America’s competitiveness by attracting skilled labor.  But is it really about skilled labor or cheap labor? Is there a conclusive study which proves that this change will make America more competitive in the global economic space?

A recent survey (http://topics.dallasnews.com/article/04GS8O506kfDn?q=Europe) shows that Indian IT companies ranked amongst the world’s lowest paying employers. On an average Indian IT companies paid $36,120 & a Swiss IT company paid a similar employee $167,8902. In view of this data one cannot help but wonder if this is about attracting high skilled workers and not just low cost labor. Shouldn’t we address the root cause of the problem and help prevent American businesses from outsourcing the jobs to low paying countries?

The employment based category also includes immigrants with as little as 2 years of experience who may not have a college degree.  This bill will surely facilitate the clogging of the immigrant applicants in this category?

Answer,
Yes, there is a problem with h-1b visa misuse. But that has nothing to do with Green Card process in general. If a company files a labor certificate (first step to Green Card) for a employee, They have to prove Department of labor that they have not find any skilled labor in the local market and the salary to this foreign employee will be competetive to the local market. The labor certificate process takes 3-6 months and 2-3 years if audited.  Follow the link to see the salaries paid by employer when they apply for the labor certificate — http://www.flcdatacenter.com/CasePerm.aspx
You would be surprised to see none of the applicant in STEM are working low-cost. Also, Employer takes immense risk if they lie in labor certificate and to take that kind of a risk for a single employee is not worth as you can imagine.

If you dig more about labor process, you would find how much rigorous the process is and how strange the criterias are, to give you an example, Company has to prove that for a given Job there is no one in the local labor market with lower qualification gets left out before looking for a high-qualified foreign candidate…make sense? In other words, if you are employer and looking for a position to be filled, you have to make sure that you made every effort to find lowest qualified person for the job before getting some high-qualified foreign worker (and this high-qualified person would be getting paid same or more as shown in labor certification data)

There are numerous studies been performed on how America can get more competitive by skilled labor,

High-Tech Immigrant Entrepreneurship in the United States

http://archive.sba.gov/advo/research/rs349tot.pdf

Education, Entrepreneurship and Immigration

http://sites.kauffman.org/pdf/entrep_immigrants_2_61207.pdf 

If you search Google with “Immigration and Entrepreneurship” you will find many more studies than it mentioned here.

Btn, Steve Jobs in his recent biography mention why he moved factories and jobs away from US and the answer was clear. (http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2011/nov/22/michele-bachmann/michele-bachmann-says-steve-jobs-told-obama-he-mov/)

Question:
The Department of State website  indicates that these 7% caps are implemented to prevent the monopolization of visas by applicants from a single country.  This is similar to antitrust regulations that protect the interests of small businesses and consumers.  This bill is a repudiation of this principle.  What provisions will be added to prevent monopolization of immigration in the future?

Answer,
is closely related to the argument I made earlier. Why should there be 7% at first place? and How does it make an employment category any fair? why not first-come and first-serve? Why an applicant from India or China has to wait 10 years whereas an applicant from Iceland may get away within a year for same job, same pay and same category? Also, there is a class of visa that accepts applicants based on Diversity, Refugees, Asylees that India and China are not qualified for already.

Question:
It was mentioned in the House that companies need to wait long to hire graduates from countries with a high population, however the temporary worker program, commonly known as the H1B program, was implemented to overcome that limitation and has been highly successful in recruiting graduates/skilled professionals from any country, a major portion of these visas are granted to applicants from India and China.

Answer:
As I pointed earlier, there may be a misuse of h-1b by some companies and those should be punished as by the law but that is not the issue with H.R. 3012 at first place. The bill is a to fix one and only one thing, that is making the process fairer by first-come, first-served basis — with no country-based limits.

Question:
This bill is one that makes fundamental changes to current immigration queues, yet it takes effect immediately upon passage.  USCIS is not given any time to study the impact of the bill, nor time to draft and implement new guidance and regulations for immigration adjudicators.  Such immediate implementation without time to put into place the detailed regulations necessary to ensure a smooth transition will likely lead to chaos for some time to come.

Lastly, how will this bill deal with people who already started their immigration petition before this law will be implemented?

Answer:
If you go over the bill and familiar with GC process, you will find that the bill would make USCIS work much easier than now. USCIS publishes monthly visa bulleting for people who becomes current that month and apply for their I-485 (adjustment of status — last stage for GC, where country limits are in place, which hr 3012 wants to fix) and You may find it surprising that current process is like a rocket science for any movement. There are hundreds of blogs and thousands of comments solely focused on predicting the next visa bulletin. With the Bill in place, USCIS no longer have to predict the movement by country but rather focus on visa allocation in first-come first-serve basis. The bill makes employment category flat and not by country.

Also, The implementation of the bill will be in phases (if it becomes a law) and takes full affect only by 2015 thus the people who started the process are already covered.

Feel free to comment either ways,

Your Vote on H.R. 3012

What is H.R. 3012

On this blog, a number of issues related to H.R. 3012, “Fairness for High-Skilled Immigrants Act”  will be discussed.

Details of the bill can be found at, THOMAS

Background: Proposed Changes to Country Quotas

H.R. 3012 seeks to eliminate the country-of-origin based eligibility limits for employment-based (EB) visa numbers. If passed, this bill would significantly change the system of allocating EB visa numbers, and eliminate the country-of-chargeability-based disparity in EB backlogs.

Effects of the Bill

Essentially, if this bill were to pass, the cutoff date in the EB visa categories would reflect a single date in each of the EB categories. That is, EB1 would have a single cutoff date (or reflect as current) for all countries. Rather than having cutoff dates for India and China, EB2 would have a single cutoff date for the entire world. The same single cutoff date system would hold true for EB3, EB4, and EB5, as well.

It appears there are those who are under the mistaken impression that a law resulting from H.R. 3012 would somehow make all the cutoff dates “current.”  This legislation does not provide additional visa numbers, which would be needed to fully address the EB backlogs. It simply puts everyone in each category into the same queue. The net result, however, would have to be something that averages the most and least favorable cutoff dates in any particular category. For example, if the EB3 category for all chargeability areas except those listed has a cutoff date in 2006 and EB3 India has a cutoff date in 2002, the legislation would result in an EB3 cutoff date better than the 2002 date, but not as favorable as the 2006 date. This, in fact, makes this bill less favorable for individuals born in all countries where the priority dates are ahead – countries other than India and China.

This bill if passed will gradually

  1. Remove country cap on Employment based Green quota (at 7% now)
  2. Increase the family based green card quota  to 15%

Remove Country Cap – Employment Based Visa
This country cap removal will lower US Green card wait times for Indians, Chinese and other backlogged countries like Philippines and Mexico.

Cap per country cap is 7% of a total of 140,000 employment based green cards available every year.

Immigrants from any country can get only 7%

  • 1st year, 85% of EB green cards will become first come first serve
  • 2nd & 3rd year,90% of EB green cards will become first come first serve
  • 3+ year transition, all green cards will be first come first serve.

Family based green card cap to 15%
If you decide to settle down in the USA and get a green card, later you get married and want to bring in your spouse, it currently takes whooping 5+ years of waiting before your spouse can set his/her foot in the US. With a 15% quota, it can be faster, much faster.

Latest Developments on H.R. 3012

The most recent significant action on H.R. 3012 occurred on November 29, 2011. On that date, the bill passed in the U.S. House of Representatives (House) with overwhelming support. The bill was approved by a vote of 389-15. On November 30, 2011, the bill was placed with the Senate for consideration.

Senate Introduces Identical Bill

Senator Mike Lee from Utah introduced an identical bill in the Senate. The “Fairness for High-Skilled Immigrants Act,” S. 1857,  was introduced on November 10, 2011. It has been referred to the Senate Committee on the Judiciary.

About

The purpose of this site is to shed light on H.R. 3012 and to help people understand it better. Use the info at your risk. None of this is legal advice.

Create your own website, free on WordPress.com.Create your own website.
Start free